This site has limited support for your browser. We recommend switching to Edge, Chrome, Safari, or Firefox.

Lifetime Warranty Lifetime Upgrades Fast & Free Shipping

Black Friday Extra 10% Off Automatically Applied at Checkout

Welcome to Five Star Jewelry

Five Star Jewelry is a women-owned business founded by Mary Rupert and now proudly owned by her cousin Taylor Spencer. Our business is more than just a venture; it's a family legacy steeped in dedication and love for what we do.

Mary Rupert's vision laid the foundation for our journey. With years of experience and a deep-rooted understanding of the jewelry industry, she set out to create a business that not only delivers exceptional results but also fosters genuine relationships with our clients. Under her guidance, we flourished, earning a reputation for excellence and reliability.

Now, Taylor Spencer, having been trained by Mary herself, carries the torch forward with the same zeal and commitment. Infused with a passion for the industry and armed with invaluable knowledge passed down through generations, Taylor leads us into a new era of innovation and growth.

At Five Star Jewelry, we believe in more than just providing a service; we believe in creating experiences that leave a lasting impression. Our dedication to quality and customer satisfaction remains unwavering.

As a proud women-owned business, we understand the importance of trust and integrity. Every member of our team is dedicated to upholding these values, ensuring that when you choose Five Star Jewelry, you're not just choosing a service provider, but a partner invested in your success.

Join us on this journey as we continue to uphold the legacy set by Mary Rupert, guided by the passion and expertise of Taylor Spencer. Welcome to the Five Star Jewelry family.

TAYLOR SPENCER

ISG Registered Gemologist Appraiser & GIA Diamond Expert

Taylor holds a RGA diploma from ISG, an AJP diploma from GIA, and has been designing jewelry since 2018.

As an honored Summa Cum Laude graduate of Texas Tech with a B.A. in graphic design, Taylor possesses an exceptional skill for creating accurate sketches or CAD renditions of her clients’ custom design ideas. By patiently “tuning in” to their desires, and then personalizing their jewelry-buying experience, she delivers a truly unique service to every client. 
Taylor’s thoughtful approach to sourcing diamonds and gemstones from sustainable mines around the world not only provides her clients with a stunning selection to choose from but also ensures the well-being of the cultures from which these gems originated. 
In her own original designs, she draws inspiration from mother nature by pairing the vibrancy of natural gemstones with the intricate shapes and patterns found in the natural world.

EYRENE STRICKLER

GIA Accredited Jewelry Professional & Diamond Graduate

Eyrene Strickler has been a valued member of the Five Star Jewelry team for over two years, bringing her passion for gemstones and exceptional customer service to every interaction. Currently pursuing her GIA Graduate Gemologist certification, Eyrene is dedicated to deepening her expertise and understanding of the intricate world of gems.

Her love for gemstones shines through in her work, particularly when assisting customers with restoring their cherished jewelry. Eyrene believes that each piece tells a unique story, and she is committed to helping clients preserve those stories for years to come. Whether it’s a vintage heirloom or a contemporary design, she takes pride in ensuring that every piece of jewelry receives the care and attention it deserves.

Her enthusiasm and commitment make her an invaluable asset to Five Star Jewelry and a trusted advisor for customers seeking to enhance their jewelry collections.

RACHEL RICHARD

Fine Jewelry Specialist & Custom Designer

Rachel Richard is the newest member of Five Star Jewelry! She stays inspired by current trends and innovations in the jewelry industry, constantly seeking new techniques and ideas to elevate her designs. Her dedication to quality and artistry makes her an invaluable asset to the Five Star Jewelry team, where she consistently delivers exceptional pieces that clients will cherish for a lifetime.

Her approach is both personalized and attentive, ensuring that each client's vision is not only understood but beautifully realized. Rachel believes that jewelry should reflect individual stories and emotions, making her a trusted partner for those looking to mark life’s special moments with exquisite, custom creations.

Her love for gemstones shines through in her work, particularly when assisting customers with restoring their cherished jewelry.

Cart